What happened on this Santa Clara DSCR refinance?
My client owned a Santa Clara condo worth $1,750,000, free and clear, with a long-term tenant in place. They wanted to borrow half its value. Their credit was in the 780-plus band, and the rent supported a DSCR loan. The file was strong in every way but one: the condo's homeowners association was defending a personal injury lawsuit.
The question that decided the loan went to the secondary investor in New York: how might the lawsuit affect the HOA? The refinance funded in February 2026.
- Property: long-term rental condo, Santa Clara, California
- Value: $1,750,000
- Existing mortgage: $0
- Cash-out refinance: $875,000, 50% of the value
- Program: DSCR
- HOA dues: $675 a month ($8,100 a year)
- Property taxes: about 1% of the purchase price a year
- Flood zone: not in one, so no flood insurance was needed
- Prepayment penalty: three-year penalty period
- Required reserves: none
- Credit: 780-plus band
- Funded: February 2026
What is a DSCR cash-out refinance?
DSCR is monthly qualifying rent divided by the full monthly payment, often called PITIA: principal, interest, taxes, insurance and HOA dues. At 1.00, rent exactly covers the payment. A DSCR cash-out refinance uses that same test to let an investor pull equity out of a rental without qualifying on personal income.
Because the condo was owned free and clear, there was no old loan to pay off. The math was simple:
- Loan amount: $1,750,000 x 50% = $875,000
- Payoff: $0
- Proceeds before fees: $875,000 - $0 = $875,000
Two parts of that payment were easy on this file. Property taxes ran about 1% of the purchase price a year, which is the base rate California's Proposition 13 sets on a home's assessed value before local bonds and fees. And the condo was not in a FEMA flood zone, so no flood policy was added to the payment. Check both before you run DSCR numbers on a Bay Area condo: a recent purchase price raises the tax line, and a flood policy can push the ratio down.
For higher-balance Bay Area loans, compare this with our San Jose jumbo loans page.
Why does an HOA lawsuit matter to a lender?
On a condo loan, the lender is lending against one unit, but the unit's value depends on the whole association. If the HOA owes a large judgment that its insurance does not cover, it can raise dues or levy a special assessment on every owner. That can change the payment, the rent coverage and the value of the unit.
That is why many condo programs treat litigation as a red flag. Fannie Mae's list of ineligible condo projects includes projects in certain kinds of litigation, and many DSCR investors set their own rules. We cover the same issue in financing a condo with HOA litigation.
What could the lawsuit mean for this HOA?
The settlement or judgment amount was uncertain. Nobody could say in advance what the case would cost. So the job was not to predict the outcome. It was to show the lender what the HOA had to cover a range of outcomes.
I worked with the lender, the HOA and the law firm. The attorney letter helped the lender understand the litigation. The HOA's financial records and its insurance policy addressed what resources the HOA had to cover a settlement or judgment.

Which documents answered the lender?
- Attorney letter: explained the litigation so the lender could understand what the case was about.
- HOA financial records: showed the association's budget and resources.
- HOA insurance policy: showed the coverage in place for a claim like this one.
In California, HOAs must give owners an annual budget report that includes a summary of their insurance. Owners can request it under the Davis-Stirling Act (Civil Code section 5300). Asking for these early saves weeks.
How did we get the refinance funded?
The file went to the secondary investor in New York first. That investor approved the HOA and the litigation risk. Then the underwriters approved the loan, and it funded in February 2026.
- Who decided first: the secondary investor, which would buy the loan, reviewed the HOA.
- Who decided second: the underwriters, once the investor had approved.
- Reserves: no cash reserves were required on this file.
What did the prepayment penalty mean?
The loan carries a three-year prepayment penalty period. If my client pays the loan off early, including by selling or refinancing, during those three years, the payoff falls under the note's terms. If you might sell or refinance within the penalty period, price it in before you choose the loan. The CFPB's explainer on prepayment penalties covers the basics.
What I recommend if your condo HOA is in a lawsuit
- Bring it up early: tell your broker about any HOA lawsuit at the start, not when the condo questionnaire comes back.
- Get the attorney and the HOA involved: the lender needs the attorney's view of the case, plus the HOA's financial records and insurance policy.
- Find out who decides: on this file, the secondary investor decided first. Get the file to the right desk before you wait on anyone else.
Investing elsewhere in the Bay Area? See our San Francisco DSCR loans, Oakland DSCR loans or San Jose mortgage broker page, or run your numbers with our calculators. When you are ready, call (702) 766-3744 or apply now.
Facts come from my record of this file. This is one closed loan, not a promise of any outcome, rate or approval. Investor loans are for business-purpose use only. iQRATE Mortgages, NMLS 1862492. Equal Housing Opportunity.
Author Bio
David Ghazaryan is the expert mortgage strategist and founder behind iQRATE Mortgages. With a mission to fund home loans that traditional banks won't touch, David specializes in helping clients with unique financial situations, including those recovering from foreclosure or bankruptcy. He expertly crafts smart, strategic, and stress-free mortgages by leveraging a vast network of over 100 lenders to secure competitive rates for investors and homebuyers alike. Praised for exceptional customer service, David has helped hundreds of families with a 97% satisfaction rate, guiding them to the mortgage they deserve.
References
Fannie Mae Selling Guide B4-2.1-03: Ineligible Projects
California Civil Code section 5300: Annual budget report
California State Board of Equalization: California Property Tax, An Overview (Publication 29)
Consumer Financial Protection Bureau: What is a prepayment penalty?





